When it comes to audience targeting in Google Ads, two of the most powerful tools at your disposal are Custom Audiences and In-Market Audiences. But which one actually delivers better ROI for your PPC campaigns? The truth is, both have their strengths—and understanding how and when to use them can make a major difference in performance.
Let’s break down the differences, explore use cases, and help you decide which audience type deserves your budget.
What Are In-Market Audiences?
In-Market Audiences are predefined by Google based on user behavior that indicates they're actively researching or planning to purchase a product or service. These users are already showing intent, making them strong candidates for conversion.
Example: Someone searching for “best mirrorless camera under $1000” might fall into the “Photography & Camera Equipment” in-market segment.
Pros:
-
High purchase intent
-
Easy to implement—no setup needed
-
Frequently updated by Google’s algorithms
Cons:
-
Broader targeting; not always niche enough
-
Competitors often target the same audience
-
Can become expensive if not well optimized
What Are Custom Audiences?
Custom Audiences allow you to define your ideal users based on:
-
Keywords and search intent
-
URLs they visit
-
Apps they use
-
Interests and behaviors
They’re highly customizable and work well when you have insights into your customer journey or competitor landscape.
Pros:
-
Granular control over audience targeting
-
Great for competitor conquesting or niche markets
-
Can match closer to your brand’s actual buyer persona
Cons:
-
Requires thoughtful setup and testing
-
May need time to gather data
-
Performance can vary across campaign types
Which One Performs Better?
Here’s how they typically compare across key metrics:
| Metric | In-Market Audiences | Custom Audiences |
|---|---|---|
| Click-Through Rate | Moderate | Often higher (more relevant) |
| Conversion Rate | High (intent-driven) | Variable (depends on setup) |
| Cost Per Click (CPC) | Higher (competitive) | Lower (niche targeting) |
| Cost Per Acquisition | Efficient with optimization | Efficient when well-defined |
| Learning Curve | Low | Medium to high |
Bottom line:
-
If you're launching a new campaign and need fast traction, In-Market Audiences can deliver.
-
If you know your audience well and want to test specific angles, Custom Audiences often give better long-term ROI.
How to Test Them Effectively
Want to find out which one performs best for your business? Run split tests using the same creative and landing page, but assign different audience groups.
Here’s a quick testing checklist:
-
Set up two identical campaigns: one with in-market, one with custom audiences.
-
Use consistent ad copy and landing page.
-
Monitor performance for at least 2 weeks.
-
Compare CPA, ROAS, and CVR before making adjustments.
Smart Combinations Work Too
In many cases, the best results come from layering both audience types:
-
Use in-market audiences for reach.
-
Overlay custom audiences for specificity.
-
Combine with remarketing lists or customer match for full-funnel targeting.
This layered strategy helps you cast a wide net without losing relevance or wasting budget.
Quick Take: Where AdsPolar Fits In
If you're managing campaigns across platforms and juggling multiple audience types, a tool like AdsPolar can help you track cross-channel performance more efficiently. Its unified dashboard lets you compare audience segment ROI and optimize based on real-time results—without switching tabs all day.
Final Thoughts
Both Custom Audiences and In-Market Audiences can drive impressive ROI—when used correctly. Instead of betting your whole budget on one, test, analyze, and layer them to create a smarter targeting strategy. Audience quality can make or break your campaign, so don’t leave it to guesswork.